Drop the Needle - Evolution of the Symphony: The Symbolist Influence
Debussy, Scriabin, and Schoenberg
"I was not destined to think, but to be."
— Arnold Schoenberg, from his 1946 essay New Music, Outmoded Music, Style and Idea
In this issue, we delve into the lush, evocative world of Symbolism, an artistic movement that began in the late 19th century as a reaction against naturalism and realism in the arts. Symbolism in visual art and literature sought to express the ineffable—those elements of the human experience not visible to the eye, aiming to depict the nuances of emotion, mystical experiences, and deep-seated psychological states through complex symbols and abstract concepts. This movement extended its reach into music, influencing composers to explore themes beyond the tangible and mundane, to evoke moods and atmospheres that resonate with the listener's innermost feelings.
Musically, Symbolism rejected the explicit narratives and structured forms of Romanticism, favoring a more introspective and often ambiguous approach. Composers associated with Symbolist music often employed innovative orchestral textures and harmonies to suggest images and evoke emotions, rather than to tell a straightforward story or follow strict thematic forms.
This issue focuses on three pivotal works that beautifully illustrate the impact of Symbolist ideas on the symphony:
Claude Debussy's Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune - Debussy’s seminal work opens the gates to a world where music translates fleeting impressions and subtle emotions. It's not a narrative but an atmosphere, a sound painting that embodies the essence of the Symbolist movement.
Alexander Scriabin's Prometheus: The Poem of Fire - A symphonic representation of light and mystical fire. Scriabin’s innovative use of lighting and harmony seeks to transcend the conventional sensory experiences of music.
Arnold Schoenberg's Pelleas und Melisande - Before venturing into atonality, Schoenberg paints this Symbolist drama with a rich chromatic palette, capturing the complex emotional landscapes of Maeterlinck's play.
These works map the evolution of symphonic music influenced by Symbolist principles, inviting listeners to a unique auditory experience that is as enriching as it is enlightening.
We invite you to immerse yourself in this intriguing soundscape. Click on the play button just below to experience the full range of Symbolist expression in music, from the delicate washes of Debussy to the ethereal strains of Scriabin and the dense, emotive textures of Schoenberg.
Enjoy this musical journey into the mystical and abstract, and may these compositions inspire you to explore the deeper, often unspoken resonances of the symphonic form.
Claude Debussy’s Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune (Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun) was composed in 1894, and premiered in Paris on December 22, of that year. It stands as one of the seminal works in the development of musical Impressionism, and its roots and influences are deeply entrenched in the Symbolist movement. Inspired by Stéphane Mallarmé's poem L'après-midi d'un faune (1876), Debussy captures the dreamy ruminations of a faun as he awakens from sleep and contemplates his encounters with several elusive nymphs. This orchestral work not only showcases Debussy's revolutionary approach to composition and texture but also serves as a pivotal point in the evolution of the symphony and orchestral music.
The premiere of the Prélude, conducted by Gustave Doret, was a notable event in Parisian musical life. The performance unveiled a sound world that was radically different from the Wagnerian drama and Brahmsian structure prevalent at the time. Debussy's music, characterized by a free-flowing structure, nuanced orchestral coloration, and an avoidance of traditional thematic development, encapsulated the Symbolist fascination with the ambiguous and ethereal.
Unlike the direct expressions of Romantic music, Debussy's Prélude is allusive and suggestive. The music doesn't tell a straightforward story but evokes emotions and scenes through a tapestry of sound that suggests rather than declares, much like Mallarmé's vague and fluid verses.
Debussy employs a whole-tone scale that gives the piece a floating, unanchored harmonic feel, contributing to the overall sense of dreamlike suspension. This use of harmony aligns with Symbolist themes of transcending the mundane to explore the mystical and ambiguous.
The delicate flute solo that opens and closes the piece mimics the faun's own languid calls and sets the tone for the entire composition. The orchestration remains light and transparent, allowing for a fluidity of timbre and texture that is quintessentially Impressionist and serves Symbolist ends by blurring the lines between the sensed and the depicted.
Debussy’s Prélude significantly impacted the symphonic form by challenging the conventional structures of thematic development and recapitulation that dominated the music of previous generations. It opened avenues for expressing time and narrative non-linearly—possibilities that composers like Mahler and later Stravinsky would explore in their own ways. The Prélude exemplifies how music can evoke mood and place through harmonic subtlety and orchestral color, rather than through overtly descriptive themes and motifs. It invites listeners into a world where sound creates shades and suggestions, opening a space for the imagination to inhabit, thus paving the way for the modern symphony. This approach would profoundly influence the development of film music and the broader Impressionist movement in music.
Claude Debussy (1862 – 1918), French - Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune
YouTube Performance: Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada, flutist Sebastian Wittiber, Alte Oper Frankfurt, December 12, 2014
Spotify Performance: Berliner Philharmoniker conducted by Claudio Abbado
Alexander Scriabin’s Prometheus: The Poem of Fire, Op. 60 was composed between 1909 and 1910. Its premiere was conducted by Serge Koussevitzky on March 2, 1911, at the Great Hall of the Nobility in Moscow, Russia.
It stands as a monumental work not only in the composer’s oeuvre but in the broader landscape of early 20th-century music. This symphonic poem, encapsulating Scriabin's philosophical and mystical beliefs, is a bold exploration of color and sound that seeks to transcend the traditional sensory experiences of music.
One of the most innovative aspects of Prometheus is Scriabin’s use of the "color organ," an instrument designed to project lights and colors in sync with the musical performance, based on his theory of synesthesia. Scriabin associated different musical keys with specific colors, and through this organ, he aimed to integrate visual and auditory sensations into a unified perceptual experience. The color organ was operated to bathe the concert hall in hues corresponding to the chromatic and thematic shifts in the music—a truly avant-garde approach at the time. Modern performances sometimes attempt to recreate this using alternative technology.
Although the color organ Scriabin envisioned was not fully realized at the premiere due to technical limitations of the time, the concept itself left a lasting impact on the audience and critics alike, marking a new direction in the multi-sensory presentation of music.
In Prometheus, Scriabin does not follow a traditional symphonic structure. Instead, he constructs the piece around a single, continuous movement that evolves through a series of complex harmonic progressions which he described as a "chord of the pleroma." This chord, an aggregate dissonance, serves as a leitmotif that represents the mystical idea of divine fullness and creativity.
The composition also includes parts for piano, chorus, and a larger-than-usual orchestra, adding layers of texture and dynamics that showcase Scriabin’s unique approach to instrumentation. The piano, played in this context not merely as a solo instrument but as an integral part of the orchestral texture, helps to guide the thematic development and adds a percussive, fiery element to the performance.
Prometheus: The Poem of Fire is pivotal in the evolution of the symphonic form. Scriabin’s integration of music with color and his development of a new harmonic language challenge the conventional boundaries of the symphony. His approach anticipates later developments in electronic music and multimedia art forms, marking a significant point in the trajectory from late Romantic symphonic structures to abstract, experimental audiovisual compositions of the 20th century.
Synesthesia in the context of Alexander Scriabin’s Prometheus: The Poem of Fire refers to a perceptual phenomenon in which stimulation of one sensory or cognitive pathway leads to involuntary experiences in a second sensory or cognitive pathway. Scriabin, who reportedly experienced this condition, aimed to combine colors and sounds in his compositions, an ambition most famously realized in Prometheus through his concept of a "color organ."
Scriabin’s synesthesia was idiosyncratic, meaning his associations between sounds and colors were personal and consistent for him but not necessarily the same as those of other synesthetes. For instance, he associated the key of D-major with the color golden, while A-major was associated with green. His color organ was meant to project light of specific colors in accordance with the keys and chords being played, creating a visual symphony that accompanied the auditory one.
To better illustrate the concept of synesthesia as Scriabin might have experienced it, here is a visual representation based on his associations:
C-major, Red; G-major, Orange-Yellow; D-major, Yellow; A-major, Green; E-major, Sky Blue; B-major, Blue; F♯-major, Purple; C♯-major, Violet; A♭-major, Reddish-Violet; E- major, Purple; B♭-major, Dark Blue; F-major, Deep Red
The YouTube performance below is a production which depicts these colors transitioning fluidly in response to the music played in Prometheus. The visual aspect does not simply follow the music but also blends dynamically with the emotional and thematic shifts in the composition, much like an abstract film or a light show synchronized to a soundtrack.
Alexander Nikolayevich Scriabin (1872-1915), Russian - Prometheus: The Poem of Fire (1910)
YouTube Performance: Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Markus Stenz, pianist Dmitri Levkovich, Frankfurter Kantorei, Konzertchor Darmstadt, light design by Frank Kraus, Dramaturgy1 by Jens Schubbe, Alte Oper Frankfurt, September, 26, 2014
Spotify Performance: Moscow Symphony Orchestra conducted by Igor Golovschin, pianist Konstantin Scherbakov, Russian State TV and Radio Choir
Arnold Schoenberg’s Pelleas und Melisande, Op. 5, was composed between 1902 and 1903. It was premiered on January 25, 1905, in Vienna, Austria. The work is a symphonic poem that marks a critical point in the composer's early development and in the evolution of early 20th-century music. Based on Maurice Maeterlinck's Symbolist play of the same name, Schoenberg's composition deeply delves into the psychological and emotional undercurrents of its characters, reflecting the Symbolist preoccupation with mystique and the unconscious.
Pelleas und Melisande was first performed by the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra with Schoenberg himself conducting. The premiere, much like the subsequent performances, met with mixed reactions—audiences found its complex structure and dense orchestration challenging, yet it was recognized among critics and contemporaries for its innovative approach and profound depth.
Schoenberg’s Opus 5 is structured as a single continuous movement that lasts approximately 45 minutes, making it one of the longest symphonic poems of its time. The work is notable for its elaborate and extensive orchestral demands and complex counterpoint, which require a large orchestra. Schoenberg employs a through-composed form, weaving together a tapestry of leitmotifs that represent the characters and their emotional interactions:
Introduction of Themes: The motifs for Pelleas, Melisande, and the themes of love and fate are introduced and extensively developed, using a chromatic language that adds to the music’s emotive power.
Development and Psychological Exploration: Schoenberg explores the themes in depth, using the orchestra to probe the psychological states of the characters, much like an operatic composer would use voices.
Culmination and Resolution: The climax is reached with the (spoiler alert!) death of Melisande, where the musical themes culminate in a powerful, tragic resolution.
Pelleas und Melisande significantly contributes to the symphonic form by expanding the possibilities of thematic development and orchestral color in a single-movement structure. Schoenberg's symphonic poem pushes the boundaries of harmonic language with its chromaticism and dissonance, paving the way for his later atonal and twelve-tone works. This work is crucial in the development of the 20th-century symphony, exploring new structural dimensions and emotional depths.
Furthermore, Pelleas und Melisande exemplifies the transition from late Romantic idioms to modernist expressions, reflecting the shift in focus from external narratives to internal states and complex psychological landscapes. Schoenberg’s intricate orchestral techniques and the thematic interplay offer a profound narrative complexity that anticipates the thematic integration and developmental techniques used in modern cinematic scores.
Arnold Schoenberg's Pelleas und Melisande is a cornerstone for understanding the evolution of orchestral music in the 20th century, providing a bridge between the Wagnerian late-Romantic symphonic poem and the nascent modernist aesthetic. This piece not only challenges the performers and the audience but also invites them to explore the depths of human emotion and interaction through its rich musical tapestry.
Arnold Schönberg (1874 – 1951), Austrian-American - Pelleas und Melisande Op. 5
YouTube Performance: Frankfurt Radio Symphony, directed by David Afkham, Alte Oper Frankfurt, December 13, 2019
As Drop embarks on a new chapter of growth, we're exploring exciting expansions beyond our beloved monthly 'program notes.' We're contemplating introducing a 'listen while you work' edition, designed to seamlessly integrate with your daily routines. This new format might take the shape of a curated Spotify or YouTube playlist—or perhaps both, offering a blend of flexibility and accessibility to suit your listening preferences.
We deeply value the insights and suggestions from our community. If you have thoughts on this idea or suggestions for how we can enhance your listening experience, we're all ears. Engage with us by leaving a comment through the button below, or send your ideas directly to my inbox at arcanaaviation@gmail.com. Your feedback is the cornerstone of our growth and evolution. Let's shape the future of Droptogether.
Portions of this content, including this disclaimer, were informed and structured with the assistance of ChatGPT 4.0 by OpenAI, followed by human review and editing for accuracy, context, and plagiarism.
Dramaturgy refers to the art and technique of dramatic composition and theatrical representation. In the setting of a musical performance, a dramaturge would be responsible for researching, selecting, and interpreting the script or musical score. They work to bridge the gap between the director's or conductor's vision and the audience, ensuring that the thematic, historical, and symbolic layers of the performance are coherently presented.
For a composition like Scriabin's, which integrates complex ideas such as synesthesia and includes an innovative element like the color organ, the role of a dramaturge would be critical. They would help in conceptualizing how these elements are to be realized on stage, interpret the philosophical underpinnings of the music, and possibly work on how to visually represent the music's colors as Scriabin envisioned, ensuring that the audience can appreciate the full depth of the composer's artistic vision.